Different Results for Exact Same HTTP Request in Different Scenarios

I have two scenarios - one I used for testing out the parameters I needed to use to get the results I want, and one where I inserted what I got working in the first scenario into the actual scenario I am developing. When I put the exact same HTTP request into the 2nd scenario, it no longer works the same. It acts happy, but it doesn’t parse out the data, so that I can access the results.

First scenario results:

Second scenario results:

Both are the results of the same “Salesflare: Make an API Call” module, which looks like these (copied one from each scenario:

Why can’t I access the data from the 2nd one? They look the same to me…